Taslitz, Paris and Herbert's Constitutional Criminal Procedure, (4th Edition)

Written by:

Andrew E. Taslitz

Professor of Law
Howard University
School of Law

Margaret L. Paris

Dean
University of Oregon
School of Law

Lenese C. Herbert

Professor of Law
Albany Law School



From the Casebook

4th Ed. Preface
4th Ed. Table of Contents
4th Ed. Summary of Contents
4th Ed. Sample (Chapter 1)


Public Resources

Links and Resources


Teacher Resources
(Lock denotes login required)

Password Required Fourth Edition Teacher's Manual
Password Required 2010 Letter Update
Password Required Supreme Court's Slip Opinion for Berghuis, Warden v. Thompkins


Contact Information

Contact The Authors
Request Review Copies
Purchase Book on Amazon.com
Purchase Book on Foundation Press

Airports & National Security
Arrest & Incarceration
Blogs
Consent
Containers
Counsel
DNA
Exclusionary Rule
FACEBOOK!
General Links
GPS
GRAPHICS & CHARTS
Houses

Immigration
Informants
Interrogation
National Security
Podcasts and Audio
Police Brutality
Privacy
Reasonableness v. Hunches
Schools and Children
Science and the Law (non-DNA)
SCOTUS Info
SCOTUS Opinions (New & Slip)
SCOTUS Websites

Search Incident to Arrest
Seizure
Social Media
Statistics
Strange, But True
Tasers
Terry Stops
Traffic Stops
Tweeting, and Texting, and Blogging: Oh, My!
VIDEO
Warrants
Websites



Back to the top


Airports & National Security


Back to the top


Arrest & Incarceration

  • Saggy Jeans? Go Directly to Jail! - Criminalizing clothing worn predominantly by young followers of "hip-hop" culture.

  • Unconstitutional: Baggy Pants Law(s)? - A law that criminalizes wearing baggy pants is under fire in Florida and the fashion industry weighs in with expert opinion.

  • Former NYC Mayor Rudy Giuliani's Daughter Arrested for Shoplifting - Imagine the reaction any OTHER parent of an adult shoplifting arrestee would receive when asking for respect of "privacy" after the arrestee's crime was captured on camera? Imagine a store's management making phone calls after learning the identity of the caught shoplifter and "declining" to press charges (which are not theirs to decline)?


Back to the top


Blogs

  • SCOTUS Blog - The popular blog maintained by lawyers from the law firms of Akin Gump and Howe & Russell.

  • BLOG: Wall Street Journal Law Blog - From the Wall Street Times, a blog "on the cases, trends and personalities of interest to the business community."

  • BLOG: Simple Justice - From the desk of a New York criminal defense attorney.

  • BLOG: American Constitution Society for Law and Policy - Podcasts, video, links, scholarship, and other useful information from the organization that takes a"forward-looking" perspective on the U.S. Constitution, thanks to the "vision" of the framers and the "wisdom" of "forward-looking" leaders.

  • BLOG: Transportation Security Administration - Official blog of the U.S. Transportation Security Administration, sponsored "to facilitate an ongoing dialogue on innovations in security, technology and the checkpoint screening process."

  • BLOG: Concurring Opinions - Group blog "with a broad emphasis on legal topics."

  • BLOG POST: "Stop Resisting" - Digby's take in "Hullabaloo" on the Marin Sheriff Department's tasering Peter McFarland inside his home, as well as the legitimacy of videotaping on-duty police.


Back to the top


Consent


Back to the top


Containers

  • The iPhone as a "Container?" ABSTRACT: Adam Gershowitz - Should the search incident to arrest exception to the warrant requirement allow police the ability to open a suspect's iPhone's multiple applications, including call history, cell phone contacts, e-mails, pictures, and browsing history?


Back to the top


Counsel

  • SLIP OPINION: Berghuis v. Thomkins - "Miranda" modified: Now, 1) if a suspect does not want to talk to police s/he must say so (silence and lack of cooperation are ambiguous) and 2) if a suspect answers a suggestive question with a one-word response that amounts to a confession, by itself, that will be understood as a waiver of the Fifth Amendment right to silence; specific waiver no longer required.

  • PODCAST: This American Life - Episode: "Pro Se" explores the pitfalls and potential triumphs of self-representation.

  • Budget Cuts Threaten Indigent Defense ... and State's Compliance with the Sixth Amendment - Former Georgia Supreme Court Chief Justice Norman Fletcher comments on the state’s declining indigent defense system, asserting that there is “an obligation under the Sixth Amendment to provide counsel to those who are indigent.


Back to the top


DNA

  • DNA Swabbing at Traffic Stops? - Daytona Beach, FL police search for a serial killer via oral DNA testing of stopped motorists.

  • DNA for Lesser Crimes - The ability to solve (or convict?) based on DNA testing.

  • A Slice of Pizza Captured the Los Angeles "Grim Sleeper" - Based on DNA gathered from a discarded bit of pizza (after obtaining DNA via a new "familial search" law), a suspected serial killer of multiple young women was finally arrested after decades 10 victims.

  • OP-ED: DNA (Familial) - Caution advised re: familial DNA searches.

  • North Carolina DNA Lab Misrepresents Evidence and Results - Falsehoods, missing evidence, and deception surround a crime lab responsible for providing evidence in support of defendants' criminal culpability when, in some cases, the evidence was questionable, weak, or utterly absent.

  • Crime Lab Lies - Bad "science," "procedure," "findings," and incriminating testimony connected with nearly 250 North Carolina criminal convictions are now the subject of a scathing audit that has revealed how a laboratory misrepresented, withheld, and lied to deliver results pleasing to prosecutors.


Back to the top


Exclusionary Rule


Back to the top


FACEBOOK!

  • OUR FACEBOOK PAGE! - "Like" us on Facebook to check for the day's/week's/HOT updates and topical stories.


Back to the top


General Links

  • "The Dilemma of the Criminal Defendant With a Criminal Record" - (SSRN abstract) John H. Blume (Cornell Law School) challenges "conventional wisdom" that innocent defendants will testify at their criminal trials, given the significant risk that impeachment of the defendants' credibility will also provide jurors the opportunity to infer present guilt based on past crimes.

  • Prison Economies - When prisons in rural America close, an explanation of why "short-term economic distress" may occur.


Back to the top


GPS

  • GPS as an Investigatory Tool - Global positioning system devices increasingly used, by law enforcement and per Katz to investigate or develop criminal suspicion.

  • Police Using GPS in Crime-Solving - Police benefit from Americans' use of GPS and now rely upon this technology to track suspects' whereabouts and thereabouts in furtherance of criminal investigations.

  • DECISION: U.S. v. Maynard - D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals decision holding the government's use of a GPS device violated the Fourth Amendment. Note how the federal court distinguishes the use of a beeper in Knotts vs. the use of the GPS here (beginning on p. 17) and "plain view" observations (beginning on p. 23).


Back to the top


GRAPHICS & CHARTS

  • GRAPHIC: NYCLU Results: NYPD Stop-and-Frisk Rates of Whites vs. Blacks - Stunning graphic of police stops and frisks of Whites compared to Blacks in New York City.

  • GRAPHIC: Criminal Bagginess - How low can your pants go in Flint, Michigan? A police department chart depicting, inter alia, criminal bagginess -- leading to, if convicted, a minimum of 93 days to a maximum of one year in jail, and/or up to $500.00 in fines -- looks like.

  • U.S.: "Most Punitive Country in the World" - Equal Justice Initiative story reports that the United States has the world's highest incarceration rate, locking up five times more people per capita than Britain, nine times more than Germany, and 12 times more than Japan.


Back to the top


Houses


Back to the top


Immigration

  • EDITORIAL: Arizona's Immigration Law & SCOTUS as Enabler - A NYT's editorial penned by Dean Kevin Johnson (UC Davis) and Gabriel "Jack" Chin (University of Arizona), noting how SCOTUS precedent gives legal foundation to Arizona's use of a suspect's "Mexican appearance" in its controversial (and challenged) immigration law.

  • COMPLAINT: U.S. Brief on Arizona Immigration Law S.B. 1070 - Filed in U.S. District Court by U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder.

  • "Securing" the (Southern) Border - $600 million dollar bill to send more agents, drones, and money to stop the tide of those undocumented from entering the U.S. via the southern border.

  • U.S. May Sue Arizona's Sheriff - Why the United States may sue the poster boy for Arizona's anti-illegal immigrant movement and immigration law: allegations of meritless corruption investigations of officials who have criticized his policies or opposed his requests.


Back to the top


Informants

  • Informants: Lifeblood AND Poison? - Discusses -- by way of the recent arrests of Brooklyn police officers -- the ethical, legal, and constitutional trickiness of police recruitment, cultivation, and management of confidential informants, aka "snitches."

  • CONVICTED: Cops' Cover-ups, Planted Evidence, and False Reports After Killing - The back story, cover-up, unraveling, and aftermath of an Atlanta, GA police department's purposeful cover-up of the wrongful killing of Ms. Kathryn Johnston, a 92 year old woman, innocent of criminal wrongdoing, in an unjustified home invasion that started with a manufactured informant's "tip."


Back to the top


Interrogation

  • VIDEO: Police Interrogate an 8 Year Old Boy - A murder investigation in St. Johns, Arizona leads to this interrogation of an unaccompanied child.

  • St. Johns, AZ Judge Revises Gag Order Re: 8 Year Old Murder Suspect - Judge admits shooting himself in "a few feet" in handling pending case involving police-interrogated eight-year-old murder suspect, leading to the resultant "media circus."

  • Van der Sloot's "Alleged Confession" - Theories on why this high-profile suspect allegedly confessed to killing after successfully avoiding indictment on the high-profile Natalee Holladay disappearance in 2005.

  • PODCAST: How "NYPD Blue" Helped Overturn Miranda - NPR interview -- post-Berghuis -- with NYPD Blue co-producer David Milch, who consulted with an actual police officer, who insisted that, on the streets and in "real life," Miranda warnings are mostly a fiction and NEVER as regularly given or protective as TV portrays and society believes.

  • VIDEO: ACS Discusses Miranda Post-Berghuis - Constitutional law experts discuss -- via an American Constitution Society panel -- Miranda's future in light of the recent court rulings, such as Berghuis, and the administration's announcement that it would seek a broad exception to the Miranda rule.


Back to the top


National Security

  • LAPD Maps Muslims - Documents reveal that the Los Angeles police department intends to use demographic data to identify "Muslims communities," sparking religious profiling criticism.

  • TESTIMONY: Laptop Searches (and other violations of Privacy) at the U.S. Borders - Transcript of statement by Peter Swire (Senior Fellow, Center for American Progress Action Fund and Professor of Law, Moritz College of Law, Ohio State University) before the U.S. Senate Committee on the Judiciary Subcommittee on the Constitution, Civil Rights & Property re: border agents' search and seizure of laptops and other computing devices returning to the U.S.

  • William Stuntz's Case for a "Police "Surge" - Making a case for a domestic surge - a la the military surge/troop increase in Afghanistan -- in so-called high-crime neighborhoods as an investment in their future and reduction in crime.


Back to the top


Podcasts and Audio

  • PODCAST: ACLU on FBI's New Domestic Spying Powers - Salon.com's Glenn Greenwald and the ACLU's Mike German discuss the new powers to conduct, inter alia, suspicionless searches of Americans' activities.

  • AUDIO PODCAST: America's Forgotten War - 5-Part NPR series examines the progress and the challenges in the war on drugs via: 1. six months interviewing more than 100 people — including former drug czars, former addicts and drug smugglers, and Drug Enforcement Administration agents and 2) reports on how incarceration of drug offenders in the late 1980s and early '90s is affecting American cities today.


Back to the top


Police Brutality


Back to the top


Privacy

  • "Personal Space Invaders": Slate.com - Identifies scientific and technological advances of 2007 that encroach upon, threaten, or potentially trump individual privacy. Also provides useful hyperlinks to related source information and articles (regarding, e.g., surveillance cameras, human chip implants, and mind-reading).

  • Harvey Weinstein's Garbage: Revealed! - Perusing the movie mogul's Tribeca trash uncovers intriguing communications about the likes of Gwyneth Paltrow, Michael Moore,Bob Iger, Woody Allen, Alicia Keys, Nicole Kidman, Tommy Hilfiger, and the inimitable television reality show, "Project Runway."

  • Google Earth: "Street View" Spying? - Accusations by Congress, no less, and calls for an investigation.

  • Satellite Technology Used To Enforce Laws - Nations and states increasingly use satellite images to ferret out all sorts of criminality.


Back to the top


Reasonableness v. Hunches


Back to the top


Schools and Children

  • CLASS ACTION LAWSUIT: 1st-Grader Handcuffed - Southern Poverty Law Center and Juvenile Justice Project of Louisiana file a class action lawsuit against the New Orleans school district for shackling and handcuffing very young (early elementary school-aged) children for minor school violations.


Back to the top


Science and the Law (non-DNA)

  • Biometrics: Bodies As National IDs? - Discussing "Next Generation Identification," the FBI's impending billion dollar expansion of its biometric database, aimed at increasing identification of suspects, domestically and abroad. Notes also the current use of biometrics by DHS (e.g., iris scans) at American airports, as well as potential use for police officers.

  • Brain Scans Lead to Criminal Convictions - Brain imagining of accuseds' minds used in criminal prosecutions in India.

  • Link Between Animal Cruelty and Criminality? - Exploring the connection between animal abuse and neglect and criminality of different sorts.


Back to the top


SCOTUS Info

  • OFFICIAL U.S. SUPREME COURT WEBSITE - The official SCOTUS webpage.

  • CELEBRATION: Centennial of Justice Thurgood Marshall's Birthday - Program featuring panelists familiar with the late Justice, including biographer Juan Williams, Harvard Law professor Lani Guinier, and former Justice Marshall clerk, Cheryl Cashin.

  • PODCAST: "The Supreme Court: Home to America's Highest Court" - C-SPAN documentary; includes interviews with currently sitting and former Justices (including recently appointed Justice Sotomayor) on the uniqueness and workings of the Court, opinion writing, oral arguments, dissenting, and many other aspects regarding the making of law via the highest Court in the land.

  • SCOTUS Blog - The popular blog maintained by lawyers from the law firms of Akin Gump and Howe & Russell.

  • SCOTUS on You Tube - The Official SCOTUS You Tube Page!

  • Justice Sotomayor: "The Phone Call" - Justice Sotomayor describes the what she was told prior to President Obama's of her official nomination to the U.S. Supreme Court ... and her reaction to President Obama's call.

  • VIDEO - Solicitor General Elena Kagan accepts President Obama's nomination to the U.S. Supreme Court.


Back to the top


SCOTUS Opinions (New & Slip)

  • SLIP OPINION: Berghuis v. Thomkins - "Miranda" modified: Now, 1) if a suspect does not want to talk to police s/he must say so (silence and lack of cooperation are ambiguous) and 2) if a suspect answers a suggestive question with a one-word response that amounts to a confession, by itself, that will be understood as a waiver of the Fifth Amendment right to silence; specific waiver no longer required.

  • VIDEO: ACS Discusses 2009-10 Supreme Court Review - Roundup of noteworthy SCOTUS decision in its 2009-10 and thoughts on the 2010-11 term.

  • VIDEO: Justice Sotomayor on Berghuis v. Thompkins - At approximately 14:00, Justice Sotomayor discusses her thoughts on the majority's opinion (despite her dissent) with law students.


Back to the top


SCOTUS Websites

  • WEBSITE: C-SPAN's Supreme Court - Includes podcasts, streaming video, interviews, reviews, and other information regarding the workings of the highest court in the land.

  • VIRTUAL TOUR: SCOTUS - The places -- including the Robing Room, the Supreme Court's Library, and the West Plaza Pediment's "Equal Justice Under Law" inscription -- and a few faces of the U.S. Supreme Court, thanks to the work of C-SPAN's cameras and interviews.

  • SCOTUS "Experts" - Courtesy of C-SPAN, video snippets of those who have covered the U.S. Supreme Court and possess intimate knowledge of, inter alia, its rhythms, changes, collegiality, and the impact of a new Justice.

  • U.S. SCOTUS Media - A multimedia archive devoted to the Supreme Court of the United States and its work.


Back to the top


Search Incident to Arrest


Back to the top


Seizure


    Back to the top


    Social Media


    Back to the top


    Statistics


    Back to the top


    Strange, But True

    • Crack Tax? - New York's governor proposes a tax on marijuana, heroin, and cocaine; prepaid "tax stamps" would be affixed to bags of the substances, indicating that the dealer has complied with the tax law.

    • Officer Fido? - Dogs as "sworn police officers." Some do "take the oath!"

    • AUDIO PODCAST: Shaming Gang Members - From National Public Radio: Distributing flyers with suspected gang members' photos as a shaming tactic is a new weapon in Boston police officers' arsenal ... that may backfire.

    • VIDEO: Dancing Cop - Swedish cop's rhythm!


    Back to the top


    Tasers


    Back to the top


    Terry Stops

    • New York Minorities More Likely to Be Frisked - May 2010 New York Times story of the 2009 raw data by the Center for Constitutional Rights that, inter alia, nearly 490,000 blacks and Latinos were stopped by the police on the streets last year, compared with 53,000 whites. But once stopped, the arrest rates were virtually the same.

    • NYPD's "Stop, Question, Frisk" - 52,000 stops over a few blocks' range in 4 years? This article discusses whether the impact of these stats help or hurt.

    • VIDEO: NYPD's "Stop, Question, Frisk" - NYT Video depiction of the NYPD's justification for 52,000 purported Terry stops and frisks occurring in 4 years over a few blocks' city realty.

    • EDITORIAL: Arizona's Immigration Law & SCOTUS as Enabler - A WaPo editorial penned by Dean Kevin Johnson (UC Davis) and Gabriel "Jack" Chin (University of Arizona), noting how SCOTUS precedent gives legal foundation to Arizona's use of a suspect's "Mexican appearance" in its controversial (and challenged) immigration law.

    • NY Limits Retention of Stop-and-Frisk Data - Despite opposition from the NYPD, New York's Governor David Paterson signed into law a bill passed by the Senate and Assembly that would limit the retention of personal data gathered by New York City's police to prohibit the police from saving people’s personal data in cases when no enforcement action was taken (the database would still include a record of the stop, including the person’s age and race and the location and reason for it, as the City Council required in 2001).

    • When in France... - France's constitutional court recently ordered in a landmark decision that French police be stripped of their power to arrest ordinary suspects and interrogate them for 48 hours without bringing charges or reading them their rights.

    • VIDEO: Interviews With The Racially Profiled: Brownsville, NY Black Men React - Video interviews with those men who are disproportionately and repeatedly targeted for Terry stops and frisks by NYPD in the war on drugs and other crimes.

    • PROPOSED LEGISLATION: End Racial Profiling Act - Most recent iteration of the text of the bill repeatedly introduced by U.S. House of Representatives Member John Conyers to cease police race-based stop-and-frisk conduct.

    • REPORT: Targeting Blacks for Marijuana Use, 2004-08 - Drug Policy Alliance data supporting the practice of excessive/overpolicing of Blacks in California by Dr. Harry Levine, Queens College (NY) researcher.

    • STUDY: Race-Based Policing By the LAPD - ACLU report data, executive summary, and conclusions regarding police practices that disproportionately target and affect Blacks and Latinos in Los Angeles, CA.


    Back to the top


    Traffic Stops

    • All Shook Up: Police Vehicles That Rumble - Washington D.C.'s Metropolitan Police Department upgrades its fleet by adding vehicles equipped with the "Rumbler," a device that emits a vibrating frequency felt up to 200' away in order to assist police emergency travel.

    • MA High Speed Chase Policy - Pursuit vs. public safety: how Massachusetts balances these interests in police high-speed chases.

    • ABSTRACT: Lawrence Rosenthal's "Pragmatism, Originalism, Rce, and the Case Against Terry v. Ohio - A criminal justice system that fails to keep disadvantaged persons of color safe, even as relatively wealthy whites live in security, can offer neither fairness nor legitimacy. Terry offered the police hope of a prophylactic approach to policing in which the authorities need not wait until a crime is committed to undertake measures to keep a community safe. ... The residents of high-crime, inner-city communities face threats to their safety that most of us would find unimaginable, and that surely those who framed the Fourth Amendment could never have imagined. Perhaps that is why so many rebel against the kind of stop-and-frisk regime undertaken in New York. The threat of violent crime that New York and other cities have faced, however, should be enough to expand one's imagination.


    Back to the top


    Tweeting, and Texting, and Blogging: Oh, My!


    Back to the top


    VIDEO

    • DASH CAM: Video of OK Highway Patrol - Highway patrol officer's cruiser captured the officer's traffic stop of and fight with ambulance driver.

    • VIDEO: Cops Planting Drugs on Suspect? - You be the judge. Dash cam films a traffic stop and Terry (perhaps) frisk(s) of a suspect. During the searching of the suspect (and use of force via repeated canine dog bites), one officer signals another, leading to the searching officer's movement to his own pocket, back to the suspect's pant pocket, and the sudden declaration of "found" marijuana.

    • NYPD's "Stop, Question, Frisk" - From the July 2010 NYT story detailing NYPD's justification for 52,000 stops in 4 years over several blocks (and reactions).

    • VIDEO: MPD Officer Brandishes Gun During Snowball Fight - "YOU DON'T BRING A GUN TO A SNOWBALL FIGHT!"

    • VIDEO: Chinese Police Shooting - Multiple gun shots fired to kill a hostage-taker armed only with scissors triggered commentary that celebrates and criticizes aggressive policing in China. Interesting/Complicating factors: 1) the hostage-taker stabbed a male victim with the scissors and took his (female) hostage after a botched robbery attempt, 2) the plainclothes officer is a woman (in "a white pantsuit and elegant scarf"), and 3) moments after the killing, the officer smiles and laughs.

    • VIDEO: ACS Discusses Miranda Post-Berghuis - Constitutional law experts discuss -- via an American Constitution Society panel -- Miranda's future in light of the recent court rulings, such as Berghuis, and the administration's announcement that it would seek a broad exception to the Miranda rule.

    • Increase in Prosecutions for Videotaping Police - Now that videotapes of police (mis)conduct have become hot items online on sites such as You Tube and in court, police are now seeking to kill -- or, at least confiscate -- the messenger. Others maintain that photography and videotaping are not crimes.

    • Officers Lie? In Court? While Under Oath? - Surveillance video contradicts officer testimony at trial regarding the details of an arrest.

    • Recording On-Duty Police = Criminal Conduct? - A growing and divided chorus of opinions on whether recording police officers' conduct violates officers' rights.


    Back to the top


    Warrants

    • Secret Warrants Issued Without Probable Cause - Courts divided on the issuance of secret warrants to allow federal agents' tracking of individuals' cellphones via the Pen Register and Stored Communications statutes on less than probable cause.

    • Identity Theft, Drug Smuggling, and No-Knock (or not) Warrant? - Questions arise after local police execute a no-knock entry of local mayor's home, kill his family's Labrador retrievers, and attempt to connect the mayor and his wife to a package containing 32 lbs. of marijuana delivered to the home . . . by the police.


    Back to the top


    Websites

    • WEBSITE: American Constitution Society for Law and Policy - Podcasts, video, links, scholarship, and other useful information from the organization that takes a"forward-looking" perspective on the U.S. Constitution, thanks to the "vision" of the framers and the "wisdom" of "forward-looking" leaders.




    Thomson Reuters © 2010 Thomson Reuters
    For more information: foundation-press.com
    For personal assistance call: 1.877.888.1330